Pesticides and Insecticides
By Dervla O'Kane (Y11 TA Oct 2002).

          

These substances kill insects that harm crops. They bring benefit by greatly increasing the yield of produce from the farmer's field. It was once thought that they were harmless and presented no serious risk to humans.  However, it is now apparent that they do! Should we then be worried about wind/air borne pesticides and insecticides? Of course we should!!

Pesticides and insecticides have the potential to produce cancers in exposed individuals and mutations in their children. The mutation happens because these substances have adverse effects on our reproductive system. They damage the genes on our chromosomes.  These genes are essential because they determine our characteristics and those of our offspring.  The material that makes the genes is DNA. It is also used day and daily to make thousands of different enzymes and hormones, each of which have vitally important roles to play in our bodies. When our DNA is altered it begins to make mistakes in building some of these enzymes and hormones. Diseases of the body are then likely to result. If the doctor cannot give you a medicine to overcome the deficiency your body has - then it's 'curtains' for you I'm afraid! 

The chemicals also show sub clinical indications of biological damage.  Occupational exposure to fine powders and some organic chemicals have been found to produce allergies and inhalation can lead to fatal lung cancer.  Treatment consists of minimizing the body’s absorption of the poison.  Cholinesterase inhibitors cause symptoms related to parasympathetic over activity – chest tightness, wheezing, blurring of vision, vomiting, diarrhea, abdominal pain, and in severe cases respiratory paralysis.  50% of human poisoning cases involve the use of insecticides, along with aspirin, cosmetics and barbiturates.  Symptoms of disease include reports of pain, visible conditions, body temperature, fatigue, loss or gain of weight, pain or tenderness of muscles or internal organs and high blood pressure. However, sometimes there are no symptoms at al until it is too late.  The pesticide DDT can cause nausea, irritability, weakness, muscle pain and convulsions. DDT has been banned in this country for several decades, but it is still in use in some Third World Countries.

Of course one needs to take a balanced view in this debate. Although pesticides and insecticides cause harm to people they also help to protect people from life-threatening diseases as well.  They are used to guard against the disease malaria, by killing the parasites that carry the disease, namely mosquitos.  Insecticides have eliminated malaria in most of the western hemisphere.  Around 200 million people are affected by malaria in tropical areas and in sub-Saharan Africa. Around 1million children under the age of 5 die annually because of malaria.  Some parasites like the mosquito that carries plasmodia have become resistant to the chemicals and new, more effective chemicals are being searched for.  It is estimated that over ˝ of the human race harbours one or more species of parasites.  Malaria parasites affect up to 500 million people and kill over 2 million annually.  Malaria symptoms include chills, sweating and fever.

     

Pesticide precautions:

§        Use protective clothing and respirators

§        Monitor contamination of equipment and clothing

§        Keep workers out of recently sprayed areas

§        Workers must wash thoroughly after being exposed.

 

Pesticides and insecticides are both harmful but they are needed to prevent diseases such as malaria and to protect crops that we need for food.  Although they cause diseases like cancer it is hard to imagine life without these chemicals, as they are part of our everyday life!!  

Hopefully we will find safer pesticides and safer ways of using them. This way we can still benefit from the fact that they save lives indirectly, through increasing food production and guarding against killer diseases.

 

Mosquito carrying malaria virus.  

 

Click here to see how multiple applications of pesticides are typically necessary on various crops.
Onions and orchard crops receive the greatest number of insecticide applications due to onion thrip and codling moth pressures. Field corn and small grains average only one insecticide application each season.

Click here to see how multiple applications of insecticides are typically necessary on various crops.

Click here to see how multiple applications of herbicides are typically necessary on various crops.

Click here to see how multiple applications of fungicides are typically necessary on various crops.

Environmental Officers need to be watchful of DRINKING WATER WELLS.
Wells located in pits, or without grout or a cap, can allow surface water to carry bacteria, pesticides, fertilizer, or oil products into your drinking water supply. Proper well design reduces the risk of pollution by sealing the well from anything that might enter it from the surface.

Controversially, some scientists believe there is a link between ICI's nerve gas insecticide and CJD.
Click here to read more on this particular viewpoint.

In summary, pest pressure and consequent pesticide management can be intensive on some farms and market gardens. Crops receive many pesticide applications each season. Chemical pest management is most intensive with onions as an average of 12 pesticide applications are made each season. In contrast, field corn receives an average of two pesticide applications each season.

The ranges in average number of pesticide applications for 11 crops in one survey were 1 to 6  for herbicides, 1 to 5 for insecticides, and 0 to 4 for fungicides. 

As well as being carried in the air, these pesticides (and insecticides) can enter into water supplies and present a significant health risk.

What do you think the cartoonist's message is in the following cartoon?
By Chuck Asay.

Return to Main Page.